Church insurance from an agency that only serves ministries
MinistrySure is an independent insurance agency built to serve Georgia's churches, schools, and faith-based ministries.
Different backgrounds. Same purpose. Protecting yours.
Meet the team →You don't need to know insurance. You just need the right team.
If you're the person at your church or school who ended up with insurance on your plate — welcome. You're in the right place.
We know how this usually goes. The board wants answers. The pastor has priorities. Volunteers have opinions. And somehow, you're the one sorting it all out — on top of everything else you're already doing. You might not even know what kind of insurance your church needs, how much church insurance should cost, or whether your current church insurance coverage is enough. That's okay.
MinistrySure is a church insurance agency that only works with ministries — churches, Christian schools, and faith-based organizations across Georgia. It's not a sideline — it's all we do. That means we already know what coverage your ministry needs before you have to figure it out yourself.
A team built to serve churches.
Every person on our team was hired to serve churches — it's the only thing we do. Georgia ministries face risks that general insurance agents don't think to ask about: volunteer injuries, counseling liability, aging roofs, vehicle accidents on mission trips, and employment disputes. From church property insurance to workers' comp, D&O coverage, and abuse prevention — we know what Georgia churches need because ministry insurance is all we've ever done.
A coverage review in four steps
No obligation. No pressure. Just a clear look at whether your ministry has the right protection.
Ministry Conversation
We start with a conversation — not a sales pitch. We learn about your mission, your buildings, your people, and how your ministry operates day to day.
Gather Key Details
We collect your current policies, loss history, building details, and programs. You can share these through our secure portal or send them directly.
Compare Specialized Carriers
We review carriers like Brotherhood Mutual and Insurance Board who specialize in ministry coverage — evaluating protection and value, not just price.
Review Your Quote Comparison
We present a clear, side-by-side comparison your leadership team can understand — with our recommendations so you can make a confident decision.
Why Georgia ministries choose MinistrySure
We only do ministry insurance
No commercial accounts. No personal lines. Every policy we write is for a church, school, or ministry.
A dedicated advisor who knows your ministry
You get a person — not a call center. Your advisor knows your buildings, your programs, and your budget. When something changes, you reach the person who can help.
Carriers built for ministry
As authorized Brotherhood Mutual agents and preferred Insurance Board agents, we bring your church coverage options that most agencies can't offer.
We'll tell you the truth — even if it means we don't get the account
We don't make our living off one policy. If we review your church insurance coverage and you're already in good hands, we'll say so. Most people who call us didn't choose to handle their church's insurance — it landed on their desk. We guide you from the first conversation to a board-ready recommendation. No jargon. No pressure. Just an honest answer from a church insurance agency that only serves ministries.
Who we serve
Every policy we write is for a church, school, or ministry.
Churches
Property, liability, counseling, and more — built for how Georgia churches operate.
Christian Schools
Student accident, educators liability, and property coverage for Christian schools.
Camps
Seasonal operations, waterfront, overnight stays, and transportation coverage.
Cyber Insurance
Data breach, ransomware, and online giving platform protection.
Mission Teams
Travel insurance for mission trips and short-term teams.
What Georgia ministries say
“Every time I call, someone picks up. Every email gets a response the same day. They're kind, they're helpful, and they make something that could be stressful feel simple.”
“We've been with MinistrySure for years and I've never once felt ignored. When we have a question, they respond quickly and thoroughly. That kind of consistency matters when you're managing a church.”
“They asked questions about our church that we had never thought to ask ourselves. After the review, we realized we had gaps we didn't even know about. That thoroughness gave our board real peace of mind.”
“MinistrySure has been a wonderful partner for our church. Matthew took the time to understand our ministry operations and found coverage gaps we didn't know we had. The whole process was easy and thorough.”
“When Southern Mutual pulled out of the church market, we were left without coverage. Michael and his team stepped in, found us a better policy with Brotherhood Mutual, and had everything in place before our deadline.”
Ministries we serve
Church insurance questions answered
How much does church insurance cost? +
Church insurance costs in Georgia typically range from $3,000 to $25,000 per year depending on your building value, staff size, programs, and coverage needs. The biggest cost driver is property valuation. We provide a free church insurance coverage review to help you understand exactly what you need and what it should cost — no obligation.
What makes MinistrySure different from other insurance agencies? +
We only do ministry insurance. No commercial accounts, no personal lines — every policy we write is for a church, school, or ministry. Both owners are Brotherhood Mutual Agents of the Year, and our 11-person team has served 700+ Georgia ministries.
What is a coverage review? +
A coverage review is a no-obligation comparison of your current insurance against what specialized ministry carriers like Brotherhood Mutual can offer. We review your policies, identify gaps, and present options — with no pressure to switch.
Do I need to leave my current agent to get a coverage review? +
No. A coverage review doesn't require you to cancel anything or commit to switching. It's simply a second opinion on whether your ministry has the right protection.
We start with a conversation — not a sales pitch.
Tell us about your church, your buildings, your programs, and your people. Our team will take it from there — no obligation, no pressure, just a clear picture of whether your ministry is properly covered.